Actors Forced to Pretend to Be Happy Over Ties at the 2019 Critics' Choice Awards

Illustration for article titled Actors Forced to Pretend to Be Happy Over Ties at the 2019 Critics Choice Awards
Image: Getty

The only thing worse than losing is not really losing, but tying, and being compelled to say, “What an honor...” alongside your competitor who just moments prior, you were hoping would lose. At Sunday night’s 2019 Critics’ Choice Awards, four women were burdened by the tie: Lady Gaga and Glenn Close were both awarded Best Actress for A Star Is Born and The Wife, respectively. Amy Adams and Patricia Arquette took home Best Actress in a Limited Series or Movie Made For Television for Sharp Objects and Escape at Dannemora, respectively.


“I am so thrilled it’s a tie, I can’t tell you,” said Close. “I was thinking that, you know, the world kind of pits us against each other in this profession and I know that from all the women in this category, and I think I can speak for all the women in this room, we celebrate each other.” Gaga concurred, “I’m so very happy that you won this this evening. This is a tremendous honor.”

It would probably be viewed as uncouth if any of them had verbalized what we were all thinking, which is: How could this happen? (We need to see the math.) Consequently, all these actors deserve additional awards for their acceptance speeches. When Adams and Arquette accepted their award together, Adams addressed the room: “I actually can’t think of a more beautiful thing than a tie, because there really isn’t a winner when we get to do such great work and we have such wonderful opportunities. I’m overwhelmed. I have so many people to thank, but I don’t want to take it up.”


Arquette meanwhile thanked Ben Stiller. “I want to thank Ben Stiller, our incredible, courageous director who really let us explore and remove the yoke from my neck that I felt I’ve carried my whole career of, ‘But is she likable?’ Thank you for taking that off my neck. It was really heavy for me to carry that long,” she said.

In the game of life, sure, there are many winners, but awards shows should only be allowed one.

Senior Writer, Jezebel. My debut book, LARGER THAN LIFE: A History of Boy Bands, is out now.

Share This Story

Get our newsletter



I’m guessing the tone here is tongue-in-cheek, right? It’s still dark outside and I’m just now starting a big mug of coffee, so my brain is super sluggish.

My first thought when I read about the ties was, AWESOME! I truly would love sharing an award, unless I really didn’t like the person with which I was sharing. Wouldn’t it be cool to share an award with Glenn Close? That seems cooler to me than winning over her somehow. Am I in the minority?

I’m such a wimp about these things though. I’ll watch horror movies all day long, but “The Great British Baking Show” has me hiding behind a pillow, closing my eyes, squirming, and plugging my ears. My husband has to watch it without me. I can handle my own disappointments, but I have a hard time handling the disappointments of others. I love watching basketball, but when my team wins, I’m like, “Yay! They won! Woo-hoo! Wait, oh no! The other team lost! That’s so sad!”

Totally aside here, but congratulations to Elsie Fisher! I thought she was so incredibly amazing in Eighth Grade and I am so glad she won the young actor award. In interviews she sounds all-around awesome. I wish there was an award for best young actor with a tiny part, for Jake Ryan, who played Gabe. Their main scene together towards the end.....I just thought the dialogue was delightful and the actors were both so natural and the scene was incredibly touching. Wish there were more parts for actors like them!